Kashmir, the longest unresolved dispute on Security Council’s agenda: A testing case for the Council’s mandate of maintaining international peace and security

Muhammad Imran KHAN

doi:10.34625/issn.2183-2705(35)2024.ic-22

Authors

Muhammad Imran KHAN Portucalense University https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4997-6309

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.34625/issn.2183-2705(35)2024.ic-22

Keywords:

territorial integrity, occupation, right to self-determination, oldest unresolved dispute, international peace and security, Sustainable Development Goals

Abstract

International peace and security is a meta-principle upon which all the aspects of international development rests. Territorial disputes pose great threat to the objective of maintaining peace and security and consequently to sustainable development. Out of several colonial legacies, Kashmir dispute is one that has the potential, demonstrated in several instances, to become a grave threat to international peace and security. The Security Council has failed to resolve this vital dispute, which makes Kashmir the oldest unresolved dispute on its agenda. The reasons for failure are three. The lack of effective implementation mechanism in international legal order. Failure of international political system to comprehend the explosive nature of this dispute. The fact that the main architects of Sustainable Development Goals, also the P5, are the top arms suppliers to the parties in this dispute. This research paper will provide a brief history of this dispute, timeline of Security Council’s engagement with Kashmir, the obligations and failure of Security Council of maintaining peace and security. It will investigate the fact that how and to what extent this failure of the Security Council has undermined regional and international security and to what extent it can disturb the SDGs agenda.

References

Books:

Albinia, A. (2010). Empires of the Indus The Story of a River. London: W.W. Norton & Company.

An-Naim, A. A. (2021). Decolonizing human rights. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Behera, N. C. (2000). State, Identity and Violence: Jammu, Kashmir and Ladakh. New Delhi: Manohar Publishers & Distributors.

Birdwood, C. (1954). India and Pakistan: A Continent Decides. Michigan: Praeger.

Carty, A., & Smith, R. (2000). Sir Gerald Fitzmaurice and the World Crisis: A Legal Adviser in the Foreign Office, 1932–1945. London: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.

Coleman, A. (2013). Resolving Claims to Self-Determination: Is there a role for the International Court of Justice? London: Routledge Publishers.

Corradetti, C. (2022). Relativism and human rights; A theory of pluralistic universalism (2nd ed.). Rome: Springer Publishers.

Haley Duschinski, M. B. (Ed.). (2018). Resisting occupation in Kashmir. Pennsylvania: University of Pennsylvania Press.

Kalhan, P. (2019). Raj Tarangini – Kashmir ki Sab Say Mustanad Aur Qadeem Tarikh راج ترنگنی - کشمیر کی سب مستند اور قدیم تاریخ. Jehlum: Jhelum Book Corner.

Lamb, A. (2002). Incomplete Partition: The Genesis of the Kashmir Dispute, 1947-1948. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Mathur, S. (2016). The Human Toll of the Kashmir Conflict Grief and Courage in a South Asian Borderland. Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan.

McNair. (2016). The Law of Treaties: British Practice and Opinions. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Schmitt, C. (2003). The Nomos of the Earth in the International Law of the Jus Publicum Europaeum. London: Telos.

Sterio, M. (2013). The Right to Self-determination under International Law: ‘Selfistans’, Secession, and the Rule of the Great Powers. New York: Routledge.

Tobin, H. J. (1933). The Termination of Multipartite Treaties. New York: Columbia University Press.

Voyiakis, E. (2019). Estoppel. Oxford: Oxford Bibliographies.

Wet, E. D. (2004). The Chapter VII powers of the United Nations Security Council. London: Hart Publishing.

Book chapters:

Giusti, S. (2019). From a Regional to a Global Power, in Potency: The EU’s Global Strategy. In S. Giusti, & I. Mirkina, The EU in a Trans-European Space: External Relations across Europe, Asia and the Middle East , 21-42. Cham: Palgrave Macm. McKeesport: Palgrave.

Journal Articles:

Amandine, C. (2015). Secession and Annexation: The Case of Crimea. German Law Journal, 581.

Borgen, C. J. (2009–2010)). The Language of Law and the Practice of Politics: Great Powers and the Rhetoric of Self-determination in the Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia. Chicago Journal of International Law, 01-33.

Bose, S. (1998). Kashmir Dispute: An International Law Perspective. The Journal of Asian Studies, 866-868.

Carty, A., & Nazir Lone,, F. (2011). Some New Haven International Law Reflections on China, India and Their Various Territorial Disputes’ () 19 93. Asia Pacific Law Review, 93-112.

Coleman, A. K. (2014). The Right to Self-Determination: Can it Lapse? Journal of the Philosophy of International Law, 6-34.

Duschinski, H., & Hoffman, B. (2020). Between Freedom and Justice: Popular Protest and Jurisdictional Contestation of Militarized Governance in Indian-Controlled Kashmir. Social & Legal Studies, 29(5), 650-678.

Eden, P. A. (2013). Palestinian Statehood: Trapped between Rhetoric and Realpolitik. International and Comparative Law Quarterly, 225-239. Retrieved from https://ssrn.com/abstract=2269020

Hurst, C. J. (1921-1922). Effect of War on Treaties. British Yearbook of International Law, pp. 87-94.

Ijaz, H. (1999). . 1999. Kashmir Dispute: An International Law Perspective. Islamabad:. 58(3). . The Journal of Asian Studies, 866-868.

Johar, S. S. (2000). Annexation of Kashmir to the Sikh Kingdom. Calcutta: The Sikh Cultural Center.

Julian, A. (2010–11). On Loving the Maps Our Hands Cannot Hold: Self-Determination of Colonized and Indigenous Peoples in International Law. Asian Pacific American Law Journal , 47-56.

Khaja, M. A. (2016). Treaty of Amritsar in retrospect: the validity, legitimization, and its subsequent repercussions on the people of Kashmir. The Proceedings of the Indian History Congress. 77, 338–47. Retrieved from https://www.jstor.org/stable/26552659

Lanovoy, V. (2015). Self-Determination in International Law: A Democratic Phenomenon or an Abuse of Right? Cambridge Journal of International and Comparative Law, 4(2), 388-404. Retrieved from https://ssrn.com/abstract=2877953

Lone, F. N. (2009). From ‘Sale to Accession Deed’ - Scanning the Historiography of Kashmir 1846- 1947. History Compass, 7(6), 1496–1508.

Malone, D. M. (2018, 05 14). On SDG 16: Peace, justice and strong institutions”, Our World. Retrieved 03 21, 3024, from https://ourworld.unu.edu/en/sdg-16-peace-justiceand-strong-institutions

Orange, J. A. (2014). Resolving Claims to Self-determination. Journal of International Law & International Relations, 01-22.

The Survival of treaty obligations on the emergence of new states, a review in The World of Today. (1954). Chatham House Review.

Table of authorities:

General Assembly, UN. (1960, 12 14). Declaration on the Granting of Independence to Colonial Countries and Peoples. UNGA Declaration.

General Assembly, UN. (1970, 10 24). Declaration on Principles of International Law concerning Friendly Relations and Cooperation among States in accordance with the Charter of the United Nations. New York.

General Assembly, UN. (1978, 12 13). Question of Western Sahara. New York.

General Assembly, UN. (1978, 12 13). Question of Western Sahara. UNGA Resolsution.

General Assembly, UN. (2024, 10 24). Declaration on Principles of International Law concerning Friendly Relations and Cooperation among States in accordance with the Charter of the United Nations.

General Assembly, UN. (1960, 12 14). Declaration on the Granting of Independence to Colonial Countries and Peoples. New York.

Organization of American States. (1933, 12 26). Convention on Rights and Duties of States adopted by the Seventh International Conference of American States. Montevideo, Montevideo, Uruguay: Organization of American States.

The General Treaty for Renunciation of War as an Instrument of National Policy, Kellogg-Briand Pact (09 27, 1927).

Cases:

International Court of Justice (07 09, 2004). Advisory Opinion Concerning Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory. Retrieved 03 21, 2024, from https://www.refworld.org/cases414ad9a719.html

International Court of Justice (03 30, 1950)Advisory Opinion Concerning the Interpretation of Peace Treaties with Bulgaria, Hungary and Romania. Retrieved 03 21, 2024, from https://www.refworld.org/jurisprudence/caselaw/icj/1950/en/16773

International Court of Justice (2002, 10 10). Land and Maritime Boundary between Cameroon and Nigeria.

International Court of Justice (2004, 06 09). Advisory Opinion Concerning Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory. Retrieved 03 19, 2024, from https://www.refworld.org/jurisprudence/caselaw/icj/2004/en/35595

International Court of Justice (2019, 02 25). Legal Consequences of the Separation of the Chagos Archipelago from Mauritius in 1965.

International Court of Justice (10 10, 2002) Land and Maritime Boundary between Cameroon and Nigeria (Cameroon v. Nig.), 303.

International Court of Justice Legal Consequences of the Separation of the Chagos Archipelago from Mauritius in 1965, Advisory Opinion, 169.

International Court of Justice (21 04 1948) Security Council, UN. Security Council Resolution 47 (1948) [The India-Pakistan Question].

International Court of Justice (12 20, 1979), Nuclear Tests Case (Australia v. France) (. Retrieved 03 12, 2024, from https://www.refworld.org/jurisprudence/caselaw/icj/1974/en/19101

Permanent Court of International Justice (04 05 1933). Legal Status of Eastern Greenland (Den. v. Nor.), Ser. A/B No. 53 ().

Sudan v. Egypt. (1946, 10 24).

Others:

Attlee, C. (1946). Cabinet Mission's Memorandum, May 12, 1946. London. Retrieved 03 21, 2024, from https://www.indianewsnetwork.com/20191207/cabinet-mission-s-memorandum-12-may-1946

Mangi, F. (2016, 09 30). China’s New Silk Road Hinges on a Small Pakistan Port’. Retrieved 03 22, 2024, from Bloomberg: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-09-29/china-s-new-silk-road-hinges-on-a-small-pakistan-port?embedded-checkout=true